By Professor Andrew Jones, Vice-Chancellor and President of Brunel University of London, and Universities UK Research and Innovation Policy Lead.
As Vice-Chancellor and President of Brunel University of London, I am excited by the opportunities that Horizon Europe offers to my researchers. Horizon is at the very heart of our research strategy and also key in developing the kind of impactful research we aim for as a world-leading technical research university.
However, researchers at Brunel continue to ask about the UK’s association to FP10, the next iteration of Horizon Europe, which is set to begin in 2028. They remember well the challenges of maintaining EU research networks when the UK was temporarily outside the programme from 2021 to 2024. We certainly have seen some larger research networks evolve away from Horizon Europe, and it’s crucial for Brunel that research colleagues have the confidence to continue to work hard on maintaining the momentum behind these networks.
In my role as Universities UK’s Research and Innovation Policy Lead, I have led multiple sector delegations to Brussels and to EU member states with Universities UK International (UUKi), the organisation’s international arm. These visits have built relationships with key stakeholders, supported UK universities' engagement in Horizon Europe, and aimed to get clarity regarding FP10.
The next few months will be a particularly important period, as internal discussions within the European Council, European Parliament and European Commission are ongoing and trilogue negotiations between the same EU bodies are expected. UUKi anticipates greater clarity on the relationship between FP10 and the European Competitiveness Fund (ECF), the overall FP10 budget and the balance between excellence, competitiveness, openness and exclusions. Crucially, we also hope that there will soon be greater certainty on the terms of association for countries such as the UK.
In my own university, there are excellent researchers standing ready to participate from day one, as there are across the UK. However, the UK research community needs confidence and certainty about the UK's place within FP10. Early clarity on association will be essential to maximise participation, strengthen collaboration and ensure that FP10 benefits from the very best research talent from the outset.
Lessons learned from Horizon Europe
With 22 countries currently fully or partially associated, including the UK, Horizon Europe has evolved and become truly international. However, with less than two years remaining, there is a growing risk for the UK that uncertainty will re-emerge, undermining confidence and significantly damaging the UK’s research and innovation system.
To see the risk involved, we need only look back at the protracted negotiations and incremental extensions of the Horizon Europe guarantee, which the UK Government set up to offer alternative funding when the country was outside the programme. This created significant uncertainty, not only for UK applicants but also for our friends and colleagues across Europe. Moreover, the guarantee itself was not sufficient to give UK universities the confidence to engage fully with the programme, nor did it provide enough reassurance to European collaborators to rebuild trust and commit to long-term partnerships with UK institutions.
UUKi's recent report, Realising our potential: UK participation in Horizon Europe, provides clear evidence that this uncertainty had a considerable impact on UK participation during Horizon Europe’s first three years. Crucially, the report also highlights the longer-term effects. Although UK participation and success rates showed strong signs of recovery in 2024, rebuilding partnerships, networks and confidence takes time. UK universities are still working hard to accelerate that recovery and restore the UK's position as a trusted and valued partner within the European research ecosystem. Much progress has been made in this respect, but uncertainty is now again risking this recovery.
Securing association from day one
The core challenge is that the UK must negotiate association to FP10 from scratch, including the terms and conditions of participation. EU institutions have been developing FP10 as part of the wider ECF, yet significant questions remain unanswered. The relationship between FP10 and ECF is still unclear, with differences in approach emerging between the Council, Parliament and Commission.
The UK Government made clear in autumn 2024 that it would seek association to FP10, provided the conditions were right. UUKi subsequently reinforced this position through its publication Our vision for Framework Programme 10, setting out a positive and ambitious case for continued UK participation. However, until the rules and structure of FP10 are finalised, it’s difficult for the UK to make meaningful progress in planning its future association. We're therefore keen to see association arrangements confirmed as soon as possible, ideally from day one, as this requires commitment from both the EU and UK.
From the UUKi perspective, we also emphasise the great benefit of association from day one through the creation of a special "trusted partner" category for like-minded countries such as the UK. Although the process for selection of countries to this category would still need to be determined, we were encouraged by the European Council position which makes some references to this: “Actively and more strategically deepen collaboration with trusted like-minded countries to the benefit of both parties”. This would provide certainty from the outset, avoid the damaging uncertainty experienced at the start of Horizon Europe, and minimise the risk of a chilling effect on participation and collaboration.
The details matter a lot. Striking the right balance between openness and exclusions, and between excellence and competitiveness, will be critical if the programme is to remain attractive to like-minded trusted countries. Associated countries already play a vital role in Horizon Europe's success and will be equally important to FP10’s success. The UK in particular contributes substantially in terms of world-class research, complementary expertise and shared values.
The EU should recognise and embrace these contributions. Given the substantial financial and intellectual investment that associated countries make, for FP10 to realise its full potential there needs to be greater openness to their participation in FP10 decision-making and priority-setting. A stronger voice for trusted partners would strengthen the programme's global outlook and help ensure that those contributing to its success can play an appropriate role in shaping its future. This would be a win-win for all involved.